Monday, 29 February 2016

Muslim Stereotypes - Extra Research

The Proud Family
  • The proud family was a Disney cartoon that started 15/09/01 and ended in 19/08/05.
  • The cartoon often broke stereotypes which was good because it's audience was children who need to grow up learning everybody is unique and may not follow the stereotypes.
  • There was an episode where they made friends with a Muslim family and explained Ramadan.
  • They even made the effort to change the characters clothes (which is hardly ever done in cartoons because it is easier to have the character always wear the same thing) by having the main character, Penny Proud,  wear a hijab.
  • The cartoon then educated the children about judging people by personality and not how they look because the mum is wearing traditional Muslim clothes and about the Muslim tradition of Ramadan.
  •  In America, people do not get taught religious education in their schools so having a TV show educate the children to show that Muslims are 'normal' people is needed over there. Here in the UK, people get taught that in school but it is also good seeing it on television because children can often be brainwashed by cartoons so having good Muslim stereotypes in a cartoon can inform children that Muslims are good people too.
  • The comments made in the show seem to be forced rather than natural.
  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ucPPdUyvzo0















Muslim Blogger - Saman Munir (Article)
  • The bullet pointed overline sums up the article within three bullet points. 
  • The first two are positive comments (about her half million fans and her inspirations) but immediately there is a negative comment (Critics have said she will burn in hell).
  • Rather than writing the article about how well she is doing on the internet, the mail online has done that but included some of the hateful comments people have posted.
  • Highlighting the trolls on the internet only makes the trolls want to write more hurtful and unnecessary comments. 
  • The reason the trolls comment are because she will apparently burn in hell for not wearing her scarves and hijab 'correctly' even though they are still wrapped around her head in the correct manner but in a more fashionable and colourful way.
  • There will always be people who share their hate on the internet but this article, after saying how well she does, then continues to talk about the haters comments which only feeds them and makes them stronger. The article is meant to be positive about her good efforts to maintain a blog about Islamic fashions but instead the article brings out the negative comments.
  • Doing this may make the readers believe the haters are correct rather than the bloggers which doesn't help enforce the articles positive points.

















Muslim Make-up Artist
  • The bullet pointed overline in this article sums up the article with good points this time. There are no negatives in the summary.
  • In the last article, it mentioned quite a few times that she wasn't wearing her headscarves or hijab correctly according to the commenters. So much so she would burn in hell. In this article, it talks about how many followers and views she has.
  • It also comments on how well her outfits and costumes are and how good it is that she can do it all while still incorporating the head scarves.
  • This article appreciates her talents as a human and not as a religion. This is a way of normalising Muslims.


















British Teen Suicide Bomber
  • The article keeps highlighting people who have passed their A-Levels and even getting a degree at university before going out to Syria.
  • It keeps highlighting that each person was a Christian that converted to be a radical Muslim. 
  • The article has the overall point that anybody can become a radical Muslim through conversion however the names of people used as examples are all foreign names traditionally associated with Muslims.
  • The title says he became a suicide bomber which is his 'dream job' however in the article it states that he never mentioned becoming an isis member to anyone so how would the writer know that it is his 'Dream Job'?
ITV News Muslim Rap
  • Students have taken action themselves to portray their good values as Muslims and to prove how not all Muslims are terrorists.
  • The rap was inspired by the knife attacks that had happened in London in December.
  • It has three quotes from the students in the rap video that each provoke the thought of how many Muslims there are compared to Isis members, and how if they don't speak up for themselves, they could live a dangerous life.

Sunday, 24 January 2016

Representations of Islam - Essay Homework

The representation of Islam mostly has an overall negative vibe in the UK at the moment. Since 9/11, the representation of Islam has been negative because, although it wasn't because of Islam, the terrorists happened to be 'Muslim'. When the news spread this information, people then believed that all Muslims are radical. Of course, this isn't true however, because of the constant real life events have happened such as the Al Qaeda or Isis, the news is constantly streaming information about radical Muslims and people are implying on their own accord that all Muslims are radical. Because of all of this, the TV and film industries are now using Muslims as the stereotypical 'bad guys' of the stories.

For example, Homeland is a TV show with a story which revolves around Americans VS Al Qaeda. An american man who was held hostage is now a converted radical Muslim and is trying to get all of the inside information from the CIA. Within the first 10 minutes of the first episode, we can see that Muslims are already being represented in a negative way by just the mise en scene. Everybody in the background is wearing tradition or poor clothing and the whole place is extremely crowded to the extent that the traffic just stops and people abandon their cars to get where they need to be. The american woman needs to wear a scarf around her head to fit in with the crowd or she may be hurt from the surrounding Muslim men. There was a lot of sound during this introduction as well. The whole place was very loud and then a Muslim prayer was blaring out from a nearby mosque. The shots were all quick to show the fast pace and constant rush of a place like this. Once the american woman was in the prison, asking the prisoner questions, the guards violently dragged her out  by pulling her hair and shoving her in the correct direction. Already this show has passed a very negative atmosphere about Muslims being poor and aggressive if they are not westenised. This all seemed quite real and true to life because the location and and people seemed to be very similar to what has been seem in the news. This proves Jean Baudrillard's theory of hyperreality. This is where the line that separates media from real life is very blurred due to the media using such realistic and recognisable shots, locations and people. Later in the episode, there is a shot of soldiers bursting into a building and blowing up people that are inside. To film this, a camera on a persons head was used. This is what is used in real life when soldiers film their raids by using a camera on a soldiers helmet. Using editing, the footage was then made black and white, added static and the footage was left to be shaky to provoke the realism in the situation. It looked very close to real life raids which makes it hard to distinguish between real life and the media. This then makes it hard to see whether the stereotypes used are because of real life or they cause the stereotypes we believe to be real life. Later, when it shows that he is a converted radical Muslim, it is almost a shock because he, in no way, looks like a stereotypical Muslim due to his white skin, ginger hair and American background.

The stereotypes are almost always negative but Citizen Khan uses this in a post modern way to parody the stereotypes to make a comedy series. Citizen Khan is about a Muslim family who live in the UK. The show is most likely a way to begin to make British residents start to change their opinions about Muslims to give them a positive representation for a change. The show uses the stereotypes that Muslims have and parodies them by making the characters very over the top. For instance, the parents wear traditional clothes and old clothes but rather than being poor, they are known as cheap. This is so the daughters can comment on how cheap they are being for comical purposes. The daughters are a lot more westenised most likely due to their upbringing in England. They wear bright coloured shirts and jeans rather than the tradition wear. This shows that Muslims are the same as everyone else rather than being seen as different. There are comical moments when the daughter pretends to be traditional to impress the parents by wearing a hijab but she takes it off when the parents aren't looking. There are also funny moments when the new manager of the mosque is a white person. When questioned why he should be the manager, he says "Why? Because I am white?" and the dad replies "No, because you are ginger.". This is funny because comments like these are normally made to Muslims but in this case, the roles where reversed so the Muslim man made the comment instead. This show has non-diegetic laughter every time a funny comment has been made to connote the humour in the situation. Traditions are still kept to like when they are in the car, only the dad is in the front while the three girls (the mum ad two daughters) are in the back. They also call Birmingham the capital of the British Pakistan because Birmingham is one of the places in the UK where there are a lot more Muslims than anywhere else in the country. This is the realistic element of the show whereas the rest of the show seems very fake and over the top but still gets the point across of Muslims actually being normal people.

The Great British Bakeoff had a Muslim contestant win the competition. The Bakeoff was not rigged to make her win for a positive representation. She won because she was genuinely the best baker there. However when she won, people complained saying that a Muslim woman shouldn't be allowed to win a British competition; as if there are no British Muslims. These comments where very unfair because people where judging her because of her religion rather than just her great personality and baking in the show. Nobody complained while she was just a contestant but when she won, people where then very quick to judge. Nadia was a good contestant and definitely deserved to win the show but a few people who still believe that every Muslim is a radical Muslim didn't appreciate her. 

Gogglebox also has a Muslim family in the show commenting on other TV shows. I noticed that only men where on the show which I thought at first continues the  tradition of men being priority before women but after a little research, I found out that the women in the family where just too shy to be in front of the camera. People who watch this show however will probably not research into it and will just assume that because they are Muslim, they follow the very traditional ways even though they are westenised. 

It is unfortunate to think that there are still some people who believe that every Muslim is a radical Muslim. Even when the representations are positive people still don't like it. Bit by bit, the media is slowly starting to make the representation of Muslims a little more positive to help prevent those in real life who may be attacked because of their religion but there are still forms of media using the negative stereotypes to their advantages by easily making a 'recognisable' bad guy character.

Sunday, 13 December 2015

Media Representations of Islam Homework

Channel 4
Cardiff School of Journalism, Media and Cultural Studies
http://www.channel4.com/news/media/pdfs/Cardiff%20Final%20Report.pdf

Information on the source:

  • They have reported the events between 2000-2008.
  • The report on the media coverage of British Muslims is based on three complementary pieces of research:
    1. A content analysis of 974 newspaper articles about British Muslims in the British Press from 2000 to 2008;
    2. An analysis of the visuals/images used in articles about British Muslims in the British Press in 2007 and 2008;
    3. A series of case studies of stories about British Muslims in the British Press. 

Information from the source:

  • There are more images of Muslims protesting in newspapers than there are of non-Muslims protesting.
  • There are a lot more images of Muslims preaching than there are Non-Muslims.
  • The two most common nouns used in conjunction with Muslims are terrorists or extremists.
  • The most common adjective used in conjunction with Muslims is Radical.
  • 36% of the stories about British Muslims are to do with terrorism.
  • 22% of the stories compare Muslims culture and British culture.
  • 4 out of 5 stories use Muslims as threats or problems to British culture.
  • The visuals used often show Muslims doing things that traditionally non-Muslims wouldn't do e.g. religious practices.

Tuesday, 8 December 2015

Media Representations of Islam

Media Smarts
Media Protrayals of Religion: Islam - After 2011
http://mediasmarts.ca/diversity-media/religion/media-portrayals-religion-islam

Information about the source:

  • A charity for Canadian schools, homes and communities.
  • Supplied resources since 1996.
  • Focuses on both traditional and digital media.
Information from the source:
  • 9/11 is the cause of the change of the representation of Islam.
  • There is a change in both quality and quantity in news coverage of Islam.
  • The entertainment changed as well.
  • (Islamists have replaced Nazis and Communists as the villains).
  • Some of the news was framed to talk positively about Islam to reduce the hate.
  • Western Muslim women are stereotyped to be either under the control by the male power or as strong feminists fighting from a disadvantaged position.
  • Muslim women are almost always portrayed as having been in a domesticated violence situation when in crime shows.
  • X-Men had a positive view of Muslims because of the character named dust who was a strong Muslim woman who practices Islam while fighting along side other characters.
  • Most children don't prejudice against Islam but others still alienate them which only fuels the notion that Islam is a threat to Western Culture.

Friday, 20 November 2015

Lauren - Stereotyped Character

Lauren is a character played by Catherine Tate. Although Catherine is an adult, she plays the role of a very stereotyped teenager named Lauren. 

From Dyer's perspective, Lauren is a very stereotyped character because she is someone who is part of a lower social class. In other words, the teachers in the sketches have small stereotypes that make their personalities recognisable but Lauren who is the teenager has a lot of stereotypes that make her the character she is. For example, each teenager has their own personality but Lauren is stereotyped to be a rebellious and arrogant teenager. No matter who she talks to, she talks down to them even though she is meant to be a student. This can be seen as a assumption of teenager's personality by adults. (Also known as an assumption of the life of someone with low authority made by someone higher in authority). 

Lauren has a set of very strong stereotypes which may effect what people will choose to watch it. Because the stereotypes are so ridiculous, it may change the minds of people who are about to watch it. Teenagers may not want to watch it because they may get offended by the stereotypes because not all teenagers are rebellious. Adults may not want to watch because the concept is too over the top and immature for their liking.This is because, rather than getting a variety of personalities, a tiny amount have been selected to be portrayed and then expanded upon. The show focuses on one personality type and gives it to all of the characters which is how Medhurst believed stereotypes worked.

Finally, Perkins believes that the stereotypes can have true perspectives on characters which may not always be negative but the problem is that they are the only perspectives being represented rather than a variety. Although some teenagers do actually act and behave like Lauren, there are a lot of other personalities which are not portrayed in the show. Some teenagers will wear their uniforms in a scruffy manner and will talk back to the teachers but not all teenagers are like this which is a problem with the show. It only represents rebellious teenagers.

Sunday, 18 October 2015

The Future of Media - 20 Years

TV Programmes
I believe that only a few TV channels will still be running in the future. Due to Netflix being so popular, some shows will only be shown on there as a unique selling point to the business. Orange is the New Black is a good example of this because this show has a big following worldwide but is only shown on Netflix. Other companies may try and join the market but due to this, programmes on TV will be less popular and programmes in the online world will be more popular. With websites like YouTube, people can also make their own online shows ans sketches and can get money through advertisements. A lot of people on YouTube make gaming videos and show walk-throughs of games. I am someone who likes the internet more than TV and I am not a big TV watcher. I find a lot of my entertainment on YouTube where I can watch people I like anytime I want. Because the TV has scheduled programmes, there are multiple times in a day where I am not interested in any of the shows currently showing so I look on the internet where I can watch and re-watch anything I want. Even with today's technology, people can pause and record TV shows at their will so if they happen to miss their scheduled show, they can watch it later when they are available. Because of this, people can skip adverts which can show new TV programmes that they will enjoy and will make it so much harder for people to advertise and get people to watch their new shows. Online shows have recommended shows with similar actors or storylines so online shows will benefit. In the future, I believe TV's will have internet connections and will be able to access websites like YouTube. A lot of people on the internet schedule when they will upload their contents however, once it is up, it is there forever so you can watch it anytime you want. Some programmes on TV will try to move to the internet and a lot will fail in the process and only the big programmes like The Walking Dead and Sherlock for example, Online advertisements will be how money is made and there is a clear view count and like percentage so the companies will benefit from the statistics.

CD's
In 20 years time, CD's will be worthless much like how a tape is nowadays. After a few years of being worthless, the value starts to increase again as the product is now known as vintage which can be expensive towards a niche market. Records where once the big thing until tapes came along and became the new trend. As tapes began to be taken over by CD's, the value of records started to increase. When CD's will no longer be a trend because of virtual music downloads from places like Itunes and The Google Market, Tapes will be popular in the niche vintage market. At the moment Cd's are worthless and are being sold for cheap because most albums are also released in the virtual world for practicality. Eventually, nearly everything will be able to be downloaded because this is the easiest way of getting music. You can do it from home or where there is internet access. You can download it when you are available instead of having to go out of your way to go to a shop. It is basically easier and quicker to get. Because of this, CD's will become part of the vintage niche and will have it's value increased. Even a lot of cars nowadays already have compatibility with phones so CD players in cars are becoming outdated today. So in the future, CD's will  only have the vintage niche to have any value or use.